- Reports: Paxton Indicted by Collin County Grand Jury
- Scrutiny Of Latest Round Of Hillary Clinton Emails Begins
- DPS Director Hammered At Hearing On Bland Case
- Sandra Bland's Arrest, Death Takes Stage At Texas Capitol
- Planned Parenthood Skips 'Political' Texas Senate Hearing
- Court of appeals drops one charge against former Governor Rick Perry
- Trump Tours Texas-Mexico Border
- Kerry Defends Iran Nuclear Deal
- Trump Says Hispanics Love Him
- George Bush Senior Out Of ME. Hospital After Fall
- Abbott Accosted By Traveler Angered Over Gay-Marriage Stance
- Obama Challenges Critics Of Iran Nuclear Deal
- Abbott Orders Investigation Of Use Of Tissue From Abortions
- Local Opponents Of Gay Marriage Vow To Fight On
- Louisiana Gov. Jindal ready to jump into 2016 presidential race
- Abbott Signs Bill To Limit Pollution Lawsuits
- Young Protester Demands Veto Of Texas Budget Measure
- Commissioner To Leave HHSC As Deputy Takes Over
- Clinton: GOP Trying To Make It Difficult For People To Vote
- Perry Announces Presidential Run
- Travis County Gears Up To Issue Same-Sex Marriage Licenses
- Like Perry, Abbott Says He'll Leave Texas To Lure Businesses
- Texas Legislature Ends 2015 Session
- Abbott: Texas Won't Legalize Medicinal Or Recreational Pot
- Texas Legislature Ends 2015 Session
- 'Open Carry' Bill Heads To Gov. Abbott
- Austin's Top Cop Says Governor Needs To Step In On Open Carry
- Texas Senate Debating Major Open Carry Handgun Bill
- Texas House OKs Letting Clergy Refuse To Marry Gay Couples
- COA Spends $70K On Austin Code Ad Campaign
- Texas Senate Panel Passes Restrictions On Teen Abortions
- Perry Set To Announce Presidential Bid June 4 In Dallas
- Governor Abbott Signs Kari's Law for better 911 Access
- Texas Anti-Gay Marriage Bill In Limbo With Time Running Out
- House OKs Bill Restricting Minors Seeking Abortions
- Austin City Council Denounces Stereotypes In Training Session
- Supreme Court Rules Police Can't Extend Traffic Stops
- Senate Backs Allowing Pastors To Refuse To Marry Same-Sex Couples
- East Austin Could Get Luxury Golf Course
- Committee Votes Against Requiring Scrubbers For BBQ Food Trucks/Restaurants
- Waste Of Time: Texas House Votes To Keep Daylight Savings
- Senate Gives High Sign To Limited Medical Marijuana
- Pot Legalization Bill Clears House Panel
- School Shooting Victims, Families Voice Against Campus Carry
- Petition May Put Fluoridation Before San Marcos Voters
- Senate Votes To Keep Abbott Promise, Scrap Perry Tech Fund
- Abbott at Rally for Charter Schools at Capitol
- Texas House Approves Slicing State Sales Taxes For 1st Time
- Texas House Approves Licensed Open Carry Of Handguns
- Texas Pushes Closer To Licensed Open Carry Of Handguns
Closing Arguments Made In HB2 Abortion Case
Updated: Wednesday, August 13 2014, 09:31 PM CDT
Closing arguments were made today in the legal showdown over Texas' tough new abortion restrictions. It's now a waiting game as U.S. District Judge Lee Yeakel weighs arguments from both sides. He will decide whether it is constitutional to require abortion clinics to meet the same standards as ambulatory surgical centers.
Whole Woman's Health of Austin on N I-35 closed two weeks ago because it couldn't meet the requirements of HB 2. A spokesperson said among other things, it didn't have large enough operating rooms or wide enough hallways. It's a similar story across the state which is why abortion providers filed the lawsuit against the state.
Wednesday morning, a group of women protested HB 2 outside the federal courthouse. They chanted "women need abortion on demand" while holding bloody clothes hangers to symbolize what happened when abortions were illegal.
Inside the courtroom, abortion providers fought against the law they argue will put all but seven clinics in metro areas of Texas out of business. "The purpose of these requirements isn't to enhance patient health and safety, it's simply to make abortion services in Texas impossible to obtain," said Stephanie Toti with the Center for Reproductive Rights.
Toti delivered closing arguments on why the law creates a substantial obstacle for women seeking the medical procedure who do not live in metro areas. "There is no reason to force women to travel 150 miles or more to obtain medical care that's been safely provided in their own communities for decades," said Toti.
Judge Yeakel responded with a question to the court, "would we stand for that for any other medical procedure, a day of travel for a sprained ankle or appendectomy?"
"It struck me as rather callous that the judge would equate the very serious procedure of surgical abortion with a sprained ankle," said Joe Pojman, the Executive Director for the Texas Alliance for Life.
Pojman went on to say, "I was rather surprised that the judge did voice his dissatisfaction with the idea that 150 miles, which is what the 5th Circuit already upheld as constitutional, that he had a personal problem with that."
Jonathan Mitchell, solicitor general for Attorney General Greg Abbott, said only nine to 10 percent of reproductive-age women in Texas will live more than 150 miles from a surgical center that can perform abortions.
Mitchell also argued driving distance alone does not constitute a substantial obstacle. Mitchell suggested a woman in El Paso could avoid a 500 mile drive to San Antonio and instead go to New Mexico for an abortion.
HB 2 is set to become law Sept. 1 in Texas. Attorneys for the abortion providers expect Judge Yeakel's decision by then, but they know it won't be the end of the abortion battle.
"We're going to be headed to the 5th Circuit of Appeals in New Orleans one way or the other," said Jan Soifer of O'Connell & Soifer.